Trends in Green
Why Green Masonry Matters
Last year during Greenbuild, a panel presentation on Masdar City caught my attention. According to the panelists, Abu Dhabi has the largest per-capita carbon footprint in the world. To counteract this problem, Abu Dhabi has plans to build the first carbon-neutral, zero-waste city in the world. The speaker presenting the plans for Masdar City explained that their computer analysis had proven that historical city planning was the best choice to make in order to achieve the set sustainability goals. Such traditional local concepts as massive walls, narrow diagonal streets, walkable neighborhoods, and flat, accessible roofs have been essential in designing the carbon- and waste-neutral community. Once again, designers have had to go back to old, architectural concepts for the design of environmentally friendly buildings and sites.
It is time to analyze why previous generations made important buildings out of masonry. Their buildings looked beautiful, functioned well, and served as a cultural heritage for generations. Old masonry buildings around the world are signatures of the past, teaching us about the character of their builders and their way of life. Many of these buildings have passed their 100-year anniversaries, if not many hundreds of years, and have proven sustainable through fires, earthquakes and natural wear and tear. They talk to us about those who designed and built them, decorated them, and lived and worked in them. Old masonry buildings are, in a sense, illustrative history books that are beautiful, alive and inviting.
Yet, today, when we talk about green, sustainable or high-performance buildings, many of us don’t consider the fact that aesthetics and long life are the most important sustainable factors in building construction. We should ask, “Is a beautiful building more prone to demolition versus an ugly one,” and “Is it more resource efficient to build a building for a life span of 100 years or just 30 years?” The slogan of our past generation was, “We are not rich enough to buy cheap products.” It was known that the purchase of cheap products meant repair or replacement in a short time. It would cost more in the long run. Our grandparents guided us to Life Cycle Cost Analysis.
Aesthetics is a major issue that is mostly overlooked in sustainable evaluations. It is more likely that people hold on to their beautiful buildings longer and use them adaptively. Beautiful buildings are also a major key in the existence of lively, interactive neighborhoods where people tend to spend more time outdoors with their neighbors, strengthening their social values. Beautiful outdoor spaces can help create better spiritual mood for occupants as well as passers by.
Thermal mass of masonry results in lower energy consumption for buildings. With proper detailing, masonry walls and floors can save energy, especially during peak hours. According to ASHRAE 90, a lightweight stud wall needs R-19 for adequate insulation, whereas a masonry wall needs only R-10 to R-12.5 to match the same insulation capacity in Denver.
Masonry walls do not need to be covered with finishing materials. This eliminates potentials for VOCs and mold. Brick, block and stone can be used as exterior and interior finishes without the need for paint or other covering material. This means less maintenance as well as good indoor air quality. Mold has been a great concern for the building industry over the years. Masonry is a mold-resistant material, since it does not contain cellulose – food for mold. Indoor air quality has been found to be effective on occupants’ health and productivity.
Fire safety of masonry buildings can help build dense and beautiful neighborhoods. Dense city planning provides for walkable and pedestrian-friendly neighborhoods, and makes possible expanded use of public transportation, decreasing the need for the use of fossil fuel. The natural fire-resistant properties of brick, block and stone make them a natural choice for new, dense neighborhoods where fire safety is an issue. Masonry also provides security for buildings against vandalism because of its strength against cuts and impact loads.
Most metal products use between 1 percent and 30 percent of the excavated ore in their production, and the rest goes to a landfill. This means a larger volume of resources is excavated for a certain amount of metal production. Masonry, however, is a resource-efficient product made of abundant material such as clay and sand, with more than 90 percent of the extracted material ending up in the finished products. Resource extraction for masonry has minimal impact on the environment, due to non-toxic mining practices. Some old masonry mining sites have been rehabilitated and used as golf courses, sport stadiums and parks.
In the area of water efficiency, reduction of landscape irrigation is a major factor. Masonry pavers can be used in xeroscaping and can decrease irrigation needs, while creating a beautiful landscape design. Pavers are long lasting, can be designed with different patterns, and are a good replacement for turf.
Masonry buildings are the best candidates for adaptive reuse, which is the best recycling strategy. Salvaged masonry from demolished buildings can give character to a new project. Masonry manufacturers can use recycled content such as fly ash, slag and crushed masonry from demolished buildings to make new concrete block. We need to have a deeper understanding of recyclable building materials to make the right choice. For instance, a good portion of steel recycling takes place in China. In addition to the large amount of energy used in the recycling process, transportation of steel to and from China is a source of pollution.
Need for a deeper vision
Is our vision deep enough when designing a green building? For example, in the last few years, bamboo flooring has been considered sustainable, since bamboo is a fast-growing plant. Is that fast growth all that matters? Or, do we need to pause and ask from where that bamboo flooring originates? How much water and energy goes into its growth, process, manufacture and transfer to the jobsite? How well does the floor function? How much maintenance is required to keep it in good shape? And, finally, how long would the floor last before it needs to be replaced?
For a further explanation of the deeper vision concept is a study done by Symbiotic Engineering, a company that specializes in greenhouse gas and sustainability management. The charts compare the embodied energy and greenhouse gas emissions of bamboo flooring with that of concrete. General perception on concrete and any cement-based product is that they account for alot of green house gas emissions. The following charts show, however, that the impact of transport alone for bamboo flooring on the environment is many times that of concrete manufacture and transport combined. Conversely, the life of concrete flooring is many times longer, with little or no maintenance required.
What does it all mean?
The building industry should be proud of implementing strategies to minimize its use of resources and resulting pollutions. Be careful, however, to use a deeper vision in defining green building design, materials and construction techniques. It is important to calculate the embodied energy, resource use, and greenhouse gas production during the service life of building materials. Designers need to be critical of the amount of water and energy used in the extraction or growth of materials as well as their production and transportation. In choosing sustainable building materials aesthetics, functionality, service life, maintenance, and repair frequency should be considered. Lessons learned from the previous generations could guide us through the best common-sense design practices.
Masonry buildings are the cultural heritage of the past, and we need to cherish them, and keep building new ones to represent the art and architecture of our times both cost-effectively and with minimal impact on the environment.
Shahnaz Jaffari is the sustainability director for Rocky Mountain Masonry Institute in Colorado. Jaffari is a LEED-accredited professional and has served a two-year term as a representative of Colorado at the U.S. Green Building Council. She chairs the Colorado Regionalism Task Force where regional credits for LEED 2009 are being developed. She also sits in the Steering Committee for Colorado Alliance of Sustainable Business Associations where policies are developed on further greening Colorado businesses.
- 72October 2008 Green Building Initiating the Initiative in Your Business By Jennie Farnsworth In the last five years, several regions of the United States have survived some of the most devastating natural phenomena. From the hurricane-ravaged areas of New Orleans to the tornado that leveled Greensburg, Kan., Mother Nature has…
- 54January 2010 Block The Sustainability of Block The National Concrete Masonry Association reports on how making the case for the sustainability of masonry is getting a little easier. By Robert Thomas A funny thing happened on the way to a sustainable built environment. While the visionaries for a more environmentally…
- 54March 2013 Sustainability Sustainable Masonry Solutions: The Key to Thermal Mass Solutions By Maria Viteri One of the biggest challenges for facility managers is operating a building for which decisions already have been made during the design phase. Yet, there is good news as more building owners and facility managers…
- 49January 2013 Restoration & Preservation They Don’t Build ‘Em Like They Used To By Rhonda Maas Modern masonry construction can be a high-tech proposition, but building with stone is one of the oldest techniques in the world. And, while, pyramids aside, old buildings don’t last forever, historic masonry structures that…
- 49November 2010 Green Building: The Changing Face of Masonry Oldcastle Green Block is produced with 20% post consumer recycled glass aggregate, which is equivalent to eight glass bottles. Masonry goes back to the beginning of time, even before the astounding pyramids of Egypt. As professionals seek to emulate the natural…